Informed viewers of the Rory Stewart programmes on Lawrence will of course have noticed the error made in the first few minutes of the first programme. Stewart stated that Lawrence was born into a middle class family in Oxford where he later went to school and university. As any Lawrence follower will know, he was born in Wales. One other error, repeated twice, was that while Lawrence was working with the Arabs his two brothers were killed on the Western Front. Of course, these events took place while Lawrence was behind his desk at the Military Intelligence Department based in the Savoy Hotel in Cairo. His brother Frank died in May 1915 and Will in September of the same year. It was to be a full year later that Lawrence made his first visit to the desert in October 1916 and the famous meeting with Feisal. Nevertheless, it seems that the programme was generally well received and Stewart's enthusiasm for his subject was refreshing. These errors did not detract from the general message of the film, which was well expressed, despite perpetuating the myth that there was only one member of the British Military Mission to the Hejaz driving the revolt forward. It is interesting to note that Stewart Newcombe was also born in Wales, although like Lawrence this gave him no particular claim to be called Welsh. Interesting still when you consider that the other famous railraider, Captain Henry Hornby, was also from Wales. Now there's a coincidence!
The photo above shows Newcombe standing on the left wearing a white robe and Hornby on the far right in British military uniform and Arab headdress.
1 comment :
Dear Kerry: Just now got back to your blog (in past months, I have moved across country and changed careers so have been a bit busy) and saw your latest post on Rory Stewart programmes, which I downloaded online because I _had_ to see them of course and being USA (at least where I am) I had no other recourse. I, too, thought it wonderful to see his passion on the subject, and his obvious respect for TEL. From what I have read of Stewart, he realizes full well that it was a team effort, but probably decided to keep things simple by focusing on Lawrence since it was tried and true down through the years. That said, I greatly look forward to your book. Is there a publishing date yet?
Post a Comment